“it has been observed by several researchers that the Khoisan palate ends to lack a prominent alveolar ridge.”
Born to click …
Wow, that’s cool.
Is this a genetic adaptation? Apparently Khoi-san also have a bump on their larynx, but when a white linguist learned click-tongue he developed a similar bump.
Was thinking the same thing. People who work out have arms of a different shape than mine.
It could be both, making it a Baldwin effect or genetic assimilation.
Interesting. Clicks are velar suction sounds. The mouth may be closed at the alveolar ridge before release but there are also dental and lateral clicks. The exclamation point ! often seen in transcriptions of Khoisan words is an alveolar click. Lack of an alveolar ridge should affect alveolar non-click sounds as well such as s/z and t/d.
In many IE languages s/z/t/d, unlike English, are dental not alveolar.
Interesting! Where does this graph come from?
Is there any information about ancestral Khoisan palates? It would be interesting if the languages evolved to suit the mouth, and even more interesting if the mouth evolved to suit the languages.
It’s not necessarily genetic. Speaking some terrible and rudimentary Xhosa myself, the suction required to produce these sounds at first requires considerable effort, and not inconsiderable force. If you have been regularly producing these sounds front infancy, it is likely that it will cause distorted development of the palate. Thumbsucking ruins jawline and tooth development, why should clicks not have an impact? I heard about this from a linguist friend of mine, but he cannot mention discoveries like this, since the taboo on these sorts of measurements is obvious. Particularly in South Africa and Namibia; we have had our history of science-for-white-supremacy, so people are kinda superstitious about the social consequences of asking unpalatable (see what I did there) questions.
It should be possible to check.
I wonder if native Arabic speakers have more cavernous pharynges, and on the same page, whether native Russian speakers have special palates.
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:
You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out / Change )
Connecting to %s
Notify me of new comments via email.
Notify me of new posts via email.